Messiah College
HIS 324: Civil War America
Fall 2005
MWF 11:00-11:50
Boyer Hall 331

Instructor: John Fea, Ph.D
Office: Boyer 258
Phone: x2253
Office Hours: MWF 10:00-10:50, 2:00-3:45, and by appointment.
Personal Home Page: http://home.messiah.edu/%7Ejfea/

Course Description
The Civil War Era was the most brutal period in American history.  The complexity of the Civil War is obvious when one notes how many different interpretations there are of its causes and results.  What caused the Civil War? Was it a war over slavery?  Could it have been avoided?   Who won?  Who lost?  Who was Abraham Lincoln and what was his role in the struggle?  What was the role of Blacks during the Civil War and Reconstruction?  Did Reconstruction succeed or fail?  How has the legacy of the war impacted American culture today?  Together, through lecture, discussion, reading (primary and secondary sources), personal research, museums, public lectures, video, and encounters with actual battlefields we will attempt to think responsibly about these questions.

Texts (Available in the Messiah College Bookstore Annex)
Eric Foner, A Short History of Reconstruction
Allen Guelzo, Abraham Lincoln: Redeemer President
Tony Horwitz, Confederates in the Attic: Dispatches from the Unfinished Civil War
James M. McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom
Outside Reading (See Below)

A Word on Outside Reading
Readings listed as “on-line” will be linked to the internet site where they may be found. To access these articles, go to the on-line version of the syllabus (which you should probably bookmark) and click on the link to the primary document you want to read.  You should print these documents so that you can bring them to class with you.  A few outside articles are available in an database called JSTOR.  In order to access these articles you will need to point your Internet browser toward www.jstor.org.  Click on “search,” type the author’s name in the search engine and then scroll down and select “history” as the type of journal that you want to search.  When the article appears, you can either read it on the screen or print it.  I strongly suggest printing these articles, but in order to do so you may have to download some software onto your computer.  The JSTOR web site will provide you with instructions (it is fairly easy) on how to do this.  All of the JSTOR articles will also be available on reserve in Murray library.

Assignments
You will be required to write 3 five page papers analyzing primary documents related to the Civil War.  We will have a take-home midterm exam and a comprehensive in-class final exam.  Your class participation grade will be made up of your contribution to class discussion, general preparedness for class and attendance.  We will begin most classes with a short quiz on the day's reading.

As part of this course, you will be asked to attend a full day field trip to Gettysburg Battlefield in early November (Date will be announced). Transportation will be provided but students will be asked to contribute a small fee to cover costs.  You will also be asked to write a short paper (2-3 pages) reflecting on your experience.  More details on these events will be forthcoming.

Grading
Papers  30%
Mid-Term 15%
Final  20%
Class Participation  15%
Quizzes  15%
Gettysburg Reflection Paper  5%

Notes


Tentative Class Schedule
  

April 31
 Introduction to the Course
Sept. 2
The Meaning of the Civil War in United States History
Sept. 5
Constitutional Legacies
READ: William Freehling, The Founding Fathers and Slavery
Sept. 7
The Civil War as a Clash of Ideas
READ: Guelzo, Introduction
Sept. 9
Economy, Labor, and Markets in the South
Sept. 12
Economy, Labor, and Markets in the North
READ: McPherson, Ch.1
Sept. 14
The Culture of Slavery in the South
Sept. 16
Culture and Society in the North
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 1-2
Sept. 19
Abolitionism
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 3
Sept. 21
Pro-Slavery and the Southern Way of Life
READ:
George Fitzhugh, "The Blessings of Slavery"
Thomas Dew Defends Slavery, 1853
Sept. 23
Westward Expansion and Sectional Crisis
READ:  McPherson, Ch. 2-3
Sept. 26
NO CLASS
Sept. 28
Political Crisis: The 1850s
READ: McPherson, Ch. 4
Sept. 30
Political Crisis: The 1850s
READ:  McPherson, Ch. 5
Oct. 3
Political Crisis: The 1850s
READ: McPherson, p.170-181
Oct. 5
Lincoln and the Republican Party
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 5
Oct. 7
The Lincoln-Douglas Debates
READ: McPherson, p. 181-201
Oct. 10
Election of 1860
READ: McPherson, Ch. 7; Guelzo, Ch. 6
Oct. 12
Secession
READ: McPherson, Ch. 8
**Mid-Term Distributed
Oct. 14
NO CLASS
Oct. 17
The Confederacy
Oct. 19
Fort Sumter and the Problem of the Border States
READ: McPherson, Ch. 9
Oct. 21
NO CLASS
Oct. 24
General Military Strategy
READ:  McPherson, Ch. 10-11
Oct. 26
The War in the West
READ: McPherson, Ch. 13
Oct. 28
The War in the East
READ: McPherson, Ch. 15; Guelzo, Ch. 7
Oct. 31
Lincoln and Emancipation
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 8
Nov. 2
Gettysburg
READ: McPherson, Ch. 21
Nov. 4
The Tide Turns
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 9
Nov. 7
Total War
READ:  McPherson, Ch. 22-23
Nov. 9
Sherman's March
READ: McPherson, Ch. 26-27
Nov. 11
Lincoln's 2nd Inaugural Address
READ: Guelzo, Ch. 10-11; Lincoln's 2nd Inaugural
Nov. 14
Wartime Reconstruction
READ: Foner, Ch. 1-2
Nov. 16
Presidential Reconstruction
READ: Foner. Ch. 3-5
Nov. 18
Impeachment
READ: Foner, Ch. 6-7
Nov. 21
Radical Reconstruction
READ: Foner, Ch. 8-9
Nov. 23
NO CLASS
Nov. 25
NO CLASS
Nov. 28
Interracial Democracy
READ: Foner, Ch. 10-11
Nov. 30
White Union and the End of Reconstruction
READ: Foner, Ch. 12 & Epilogue
Dec. 1
The Civil War and Popular Culture
READ:  Horwitz, Ch. 1-4
Dec. 5
Remembering the Civil War
READ: Horwitz, Ch. 4-7
Dec. 7
Remembering the Civil War
READ: Horwitz, Ch. 10
Dec. 9
Remembering the Civil War
READ: Horwitz, Ch. 11, 14, 15
FINAL
Monday, Dec. 12, 10:30-12:30


Papers:  
You will write 3 five-page papers analyzing a particular primary document (or set of documents) related to the Civil War and Reconstruction Era.  The papers should: 1).  Place the document in the proper historical context (the who, what, when, where, and why of the document); 2).  Summarize the important themes of the document; 3).  Discuss how the particular document offers insight into the Civil War era with a particular focus on the question I have raised for each document.  In order to do this, you may need to consult additional secondary sources.  If you do consult secondary sources, please cite them in endnotes.

You will be required to choose one paper from each of the following categories.  The due dates are staggered.

GROUP ONE:
1).  Read Frederick Douglass's 1852 Speech "The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro."  How should "negroes" respond to the 4th of July and what does this speech tell us about the ideas of the abolitionist movement on the eve of the Civil War.  Due September 21

2).  Read John C. Calhoun's 1837 Speech, "Slavery is a Positive Good."  How did Calhoun argue on behalf of the institution of slavery?  Due September 28

3).  Read Abraham Lincoln's 1858 "House Divided" speech.  How does it reflect Lincoln's view of the political crisis facing America during the 1850s?  Due October 12

GROUP TWO:
1).  Read Jefferson Davis's Farewell Speech to the United States Senate.  Why did Mississippi (and by extension the entire Confederacy) secede from the Union?  Due October 19

2).  Read Carlton McCarthy's "Detailed Minutiae of Soldier Life in the Army of Northern Virginia" (Parts 1, 2, 3 & 4).  Describe the life of an ordinary soldier in the Confederate army. Due October 28

3).  Read the Diary of Carrie Berry, a ten year old resident of Atlanta.  How did the Civil War effect ordinary citizens and what does Berry's diary tell us about the war's Atlanta campaign of 1864-1865? Due November 9

GROUP THREE:
1).  Read the 1866 Atlantic Monthly essay entitled "Three Months Among the Reconstructionists."  What does this tell us about the early years of Reconstruction?  Due November 18

2). Read Frederick Douglass 1866 Atlantic Monthly essay entitled "Reconstruction."  What is Douglass trying to accomplish in this piece? Due November 30

3).  Discuss the impact of the Ku Klux Klan during Reconstruction through an analysis of FOUR OR MORE of the following political cartoons that appeared in Harper's Weekly between 1868 and 1871